KELOMPOK DEBAT
• Amanda Putri (03)
• Audrey kaylanastiti (04)
• Nazwa noer (19)
• Sami aliyah (25)
Assalamualaikum
Moderator : The number of students who do not have a
sim to ride a motorbike to school is certainly not a strange thing. Yes, bringing
a motorbike to school does have a positive impact, but on the other hand it has
a negative impact. As is currently happening, several cases have occurred,
because students bring motorbikes to school. WHO (World Health Organization)
notes that 1 million people die every year worldwide due to accidents, where
40% of them are 25 years old and 60% are less than 25 years old, ranging in age
from children and adolescents.
So, today we will discuss whether minors can ride motorbikes
to school without a SIM? And are there any negative and positive impacts?
But before we start I will set out the rules for this
discussion
1 I will give each a chance but when the pros are talking,
the cons should not cut it and vice versa
In order not to extend the time anymore, let's start from
the pro camp, namely Fery's brother to Fery, we welcome
Nazwa (pro): thank you Moderator, so I agree with
students who bring motorbikes to school. By riding a motorbike to school for
students, it will certainly have several positive impacts, including:
1. By bringing a motorbike to the
school, students can save time on the trip because they don't have to wait for
public transportation or public transportation with no clear departure or
arrival, which will waste students' time, thus making students arrive late at
school.
2. Bringing a motorbike to school
can also save students pocket money, because the money does not need to be used
to pay for public transportation.
3. By driving a motorbike to
school, students will not be a bother for parents who have to take their
children to school. Because not all parents are at home when their children
want to leave school. Many parents are more concerned with their work so as not
to be late, so that the child is not taken care of.
4. And also, by bringing their own
motorbike to school, students will feel more comfortable and safe, compared to
taking public transportation, because there are many other passengers who will
disturb the comfort of students, such as passengers who smoke, passengers whose
body odor or sweat causes feelings student comfort will be reduced, so students
think they don't want to take public transportation anymore. thank you
Moderator : Well now we will listen to the words of
the contra, namely Samii
Sami (contra): thank yo, Moderator I disagree with Nazwa and
students who carry motorbikes without a SIM, because according to regulations
for motor vehicle drivers who are underage / do not have a SIM, it is
prohibited to ride a motorbike and for motorized vehicle drivers who If they do
not have a driver's license, they will face a maximum imprisonment of 4 months
or a maximum fine of Rp. 1,000,000. And although it is forbidden to ride
motorbikes, there are still many students who dare to bring their motorbikes to
school. And also many negative impacts, namely:
1. Students who ride motorbikes to
school may experience unwanted things, such as accidents
2. And when carrying out strict
guard on several routes of travel. The police chief will detain those who do
not obey traffic rules include students who are still minors.
3. Students who ride motorbikes too
often, will feel bored, so take the initiative to find new things, such as
establishing a gang of motorbikes.
4. Driving a motorbike is certainly
a very fun thing for beginners, because riding a motorbike is something that is
fun, it can reduce students' learning concentration because they think about
the joy of driving.
5. In general, minors cannot
control their emotions while on the road
According to police officers, traffic violations involving
underage students have reached tens of thousands of cases. One of them does not
have a SIM or driver's license.
It is unfortunate that the case of students bringing new
motorbikes has become a concern after many negative impacts. All parties must
unite & work together in cracking down on students who bring motorized
vehicles considering that there are still many students who violate and the
negative impacts caused. Thank you
Moderatorg: Now I am again giving the pro camp the
opportunity to speak, namely Manda
Manda(pro): thank you, Moderator. I agree if a
student brings a motorbike to school without bringing a driver's license,
because it is natural. Because schoolchildren are predominantly underage and if
they want to go to school with the motorbike to school, students can avoid the
negative side of public transportation, namely if students take public
transportation to school, it is certain that the angkot is sometimes not
suitable to be boarded and it smells like public transportation. or the smell
of sweat. And sometimes students also do not get proper seats so students take
the angkot, the angkot is how students learn at school will be disturbed. As
students will not concentrate on learning. So in my opinion, if for example students
bring motorbikes to school, it is only natural because it can save time. And if
minors cannot control their emotions, are there any data or theories that can
be shown?
Moderator: Now I am again giving the opportunity to
the contra camp, namely Audrey
Audrey (contra): thank you Moderatorr, I do not agree
with Manda because by using public transportation or being delivered there is a
possibility of accidents and when talking about the theory of children who
cannot control their emotions, I have, according to Harlock, calling the
adolescent period as a stress and stress period where emotional tension
increases as a result of physical and glandular changes. The heightened
emotions in adolescent boys and girls can occur as a result of social conditions
as a reaction to the changes that occur in adolescents. That's a theory that
explains children who have not been able to control their emotions, thank you
Moderatir: Well, that's our discussion today, the
conclusion is that children who bring motorbikes under age have a positive and
negative impact, but it's better for minors not to bring their motorbikes to
school because there is no permit and can't control their emotions.
wasalamualaikum wr wb
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar